Moontanman, on 15 July 2011 - 12:19 PM, said:
What a wonderful report! I look forward to reading it – though as something in the murky region between science fiction and non-fiction.
It’s author and cited contributors appear a who’s who list of pseudo scientists, most related to paranormal research – ESP, remote viewing, UFO-ology, and stranger stuff. Many of these folk have good physics backgrounds and have done respectable, if not standout, work in their the field, later becoming “disrespectable” through because of their acceptance of claims of psychic abilities and similar weirdness.
Uri Geller and similar folk figure prominently in many of their biographies.
Being disrespectable, and even mentally deranged, doesn’t disqualify one from having interesting and intelligent ideas – though it does mean the reader needs to be careful about accepting those ideas.
Quote
And the really wild stuff starts at page 58, almost sounds like techobabble from star trek....
This section seems to be mostly base on Hal Puthoff’s ideas about getting energy from vacuum. As
his wikipedia page accounts, Pufhoff is a colorful character.
Getting energy from vacuum is in principle possible, and via experiments such as Casimir’s, has been demonstrated pretty conclusively to be physically real. The energies are, however, tiny compared to the mass and energy required by the machines to get them. Still, if these demonstrations could be made many orders of magnitude more efficient, they could in principle be used to “get something from (classically) nothing”, which could be revolutionary for spacecraft engineering. I’m nearly certain, though, that people who currently claim to have had success or be near breakthrough in such engineering (as best I can tell, Puthoff makes no such claim in any publication) are either deluded, or lying to win affection and/or money from poorly educated, credulous people. It’s fair, IMHIO, to call their writing and talk technobabble.
Nonetheless, I find it’s fascinating stuff, and think if may someday be of real engineering value.
Moderator: Computers and Technology; Medical Science; Science Projects and Homework; Philosophy of Science; Physics and Mathematics; Environmental Studies :)